i have been coming home and listening to fleet foxes for a week everyday (which has been absolutely wonderful). and prompted by my incomplete answer to my friend's question of kid A vinyl vs mp3, the difference is very clear with fleet foxes.i listened all the way through with a decent playback device (cd player, to remove my my mp3 hate on the format or the computer) of the fleet foxes and then back to my LP. the difference its rather stark, and not in a good way for the cd. the cd reproduces the sounds extremely accurate, its easy to tell that each recorded sound was reproduced with surgical precision. but thats the thing, closing my eyes it felt like i was listening to six different sources for each sound, drums here vocal there guitar other there. it wasnt stage presence, that sounds good, this sounded disorganized, it was almost as if each thing was slightly out of sync with the other it was so separated. so in this case its not so much that the detail is better on vinyl, (though it may be debatable i contest despite wow/flutter/rumble that vinyl is still more faithful to the intended sound detail-wise) but its more that the sound with a detailed cd sounds like eating something with a metallic taste. yes- that works for me, cd's are like eating food with utensils with that metallic taste, vinyl is like eating with....a spoon that doesn't leave a metallic taste. wooden spoon. you can get used to the metallic taste, you might not even taste it anymore, but when you take away the metallic taste you notice that its gone and start to notice the food. hearing fleet foxes on cd is plenty great but LP has this warmth and musicality that i believe sounds a whole lot more like what it sounds like on stage. cd is good but has this aseptic metallic feel to it. where the sounds were so cluttered on cd, on LP they maintain their distinct clarity but blend better, more musical.
[from roodavegas]







